YARN vs NPM: Which One is Best to Choose

What is Yarn?

Yarn is a package manager that was developed by Facebook for addressing the limitations and performance issueS which were found while using npm. Its main objective is to offer reliable and fast dependency installations. It has the features like concurrent and parallel operations, caching and deterministic dependency resolution. It gained its popularity because of its improvements and ease of use.

What is NPM?

Npm refers to the Node Package Manager. It is the default package manager for Node.js, which is a Javascript runtime environment. Npm has been very popular for a long time and has increased its popularity. It has a  vast user base. It offers a robust package registry. It enables the developers to install, manage and publish the packages very easily.

                                Interested in learning Splunk Join HKR and Learn more on Splunk Certification Course!

Installation and Setup

Yarn:

For installing Yarn, we need to have Node.js and npm installed on the machine. Once Node.js and npm are installed, Yarn can be installed globally by executing the below command in the terminal:

npm install -g yarn

This command uses npm for installing Yarn globally on the system. After successful installation, we can use the `yarn` command in the terminal to run Yarn commands for managing packages in the projects.
npm:

npm comes along with Node.js, so when we install Node.js, npm is automatically installed as well. To check if npm is installed, we can execute the below command in the terminal:

npm -v

If npm is installed, the version number will be displayed. If npm is not installed, we can download and install Node.js, that includes npm.

When npm is installed, we can use it to manage packages in the JavaScript projects. We can use the `npm` command in the terminal to execute npm commands for package installation, removal, and other operations.

Both Yarn and npm depend on a `package.json` file for managing the project dependencies. This file lists the required packages and their versions. We can generate a `package.json` file using the `yarn init` or `npm init` commands, and then include dependencies to it manually or through package installation commands.

Splunk Training

• Master Your Craft
• Lifetime LMS & Faculty Access
• 24/7 online expert support
• Real-world & Project Based Learning

Explore Curriculum

YARN VS NPM

Let's dive into a detailed comparison of Yarn and npm, and explore their features, performance, and usage in JavaScript development.

YARN Vs NPM Features:

Yarn

• Parallel and Concurrent Operations: Yarn introduced parallel and concurrent installations, allowing quicker dependency resolution and installation.
• Deterministic Dependency Resolution: Yarn ensures consistent installations by using a deterministic algorithm and generating a yarn.lock file.
• Workspaces: Yarn supports workspaces, allowing developers to manage multiple packages within a single top-level project.
• Offline Mode: Yarn provides an offline mirror feature, allowing developers to install packages without an internet connection.
• Selective Version Resolution: Yarn offers the ability to selectively resolve vulnerable or outdated packages without upgrading all dependencies.

NPM

• Extensive Package Registry: npm hosts a vast collection of open-source JavaScript packages in its central registry.
• Semantic Versioning (SemVer): npm follows the SemVer principles, enabling developers to specify version ranges for dependencies.
• Package Publishing: npm allows developers to publish their own packages to the registry, fostering a rich ecosystem.
• Script Execution: npm enables running custom scripts defined in the package.json file, facilitating create processes and automation.
• Integrated Version Control: npm integrates with Git seamlessly, enabling easy installation of packages from Git repositories.

YARN Vs NPM Performance:

YARN

• Faster Installations: Yarn's parallel and concurrent operations, along with caching, offers quicker dependency installations.
• Deterministic Resolution: Yarn's deterministic algorithm ensures consistent and reproducible installations.
• Offline Mode: Yarn's offline mirror feature allows for installations without an internet connection.

NPM

• Improved Performance: Recent versions of npm have made significant performance enhancements, closing the gap with Yarn.
• Package-lock Format: npm introduced the package-lock.json format, improving installation speed and ensuring reproducible builds.
• Cached Dependencies: npm caches installed packages, reducing download time for subsequent installations.

YARN Vs NPM Dependency Resolution:

Yarn:

• Deterministic Algorithm: Yarn uses a deterministic algorithm that guarantees consistent installations across different environments.
• yarn.lock: Yarn generates a yarn.lock file, locking down the exact versions of packages.

NPM

• Flexible Version Matching: npm allows for more flexibility in version matching, providing a broader range of compatible package versions.
  
• package-lock.json: npm utilizes the package-lock.json file to ensure reproducible installations.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel to get new updates..!

Subscribe

YARN VS NPM Usage and Community:

Yarn:

• Growing Community: Yarn has gained popularity and has a growing community of users.
• npm Compatibility: Yarn is compatible with the npm registry, allowing seamless integration with the vast ecosystem of npm packages.

NPM:

• Established and Widely Used: npm has been the default package manager for Node.js for a long time and has a vast user base.
• Large Package Registry: npm hosts an extensive collection of packages, making it a go-to choice for many developers.
• Framework and Tool Support: npm enjoys extensive support and integration with various JavaScript frameworks, build tools, and development environments.

YARN VS NPM Development and Maintenance:

Yarn:

• Release Cycle: Yarn has a more deliberate release cycle, introducing significant updates and improvements at regular intervals.

NPM:

• Default Choice for Node.js: npm comes pre-installed with Node.js, making it the default choice for most Node.js projects.
  
• Active Development: npm is actively maintained and frequently updated to address user needs and enhance performance.

Both Yarn and npm have their strengths and are widely used in the JavaScript ecosystem. The choice between Yarn and npm ultimately depends on the specific needs and preferences of developers and the requirements of the project at hand.

YARN Vs NPM Compatibility and Interoperability:

Yarn:

• Drop-in Replacement: Yarn is designed to be a drop-in replacement for npm and is highly compatible with existing npm projects.
• npm Compatibility: Yarn can seamlessly work with projects that have a package.json and package-lock.json generated by npm.

NPM:

• Broad Compatibility: npm is widely supported and integrated into many JavaScript frameworks, build tools, and development environments.
• Standard Choice: Many tools and services assume the use of npm as the default package manager, ensuring broad compatibility.

YARN Vs NPM Compatibility and Interoperability:

Yarn:

• Drop-in Replacement: Yarn is designed to be a drop-in replacement for npm and is highly compatible with existing npm projects.
• npm Compatibility: Yarn can seamlessly work with projects that have a package.json and package-lock.json generated by npm.

NPM:

• Broad Compatibility: npm is widely supported and integrated into many JavaScript frameworks, build tools, and development environments.
• Standard Choice: Many tools and services assume the use of npm as the default package manager, ensuring broad compatibility.

YARN Vs NPM Security and Package Integrity:

Yarn:

• Checksum-based Integrity: Yarn uses checksum-based integrity checks to ensure the security and integrity of installed packages.
• Offline Mirror: Yarn's offline mirror feature allows developers to verify the integrity of packages even without an internet connection.

NPM:

• Vulnerability Scanning: npm provides vulnerability scanning and advisories, alerting developers to potential security issues in their dependencies.
• npm audit: npm introduced the `npm audit` command, allowing developers to identify and resolve package vulnerabilities.

          Top 70 frequently asked Splunk interview questions & answers for freshers & experienced professionals

Conclusion:

Both Yarn and npm have their unique features, performance optimizations, and community support. Yarn initially gained popularity for its performance improvements, while npm has made significant strides in recent updates. Developers can choose between Yarn and npm based on their specific needs, existing project setup, and personal preferences. Regardless of the choice, both package managers provide essential functionality for managing JavaScript dependencies and play a vital role in the development workflow.